How Online Reviews Shape Local Search Rankings – Best 2024 guide

You are currently viewing How Online Reviews Shape Local Search Rankings – Best 2024 guide

Today, the voice of the customer has never been louder or more influential. As businesses strive to establish their online presence, they are quickly realizing that it’s not just about having a sleek website or an active social media profile. The real game-changer? Online reviews

These seemingly simple feedback mechanisms have transformed into powerful tools that shape how businesses are perceived, how they rank in local search results, and ultimately, how successful they are in building brand awareness and converting potential leads into loyal customers. 

So in this post, we will delve deep into the pivotal role of online reviews in today’s digital age and explore their impact on local Search Engine Optimization (SEO) strategies for businesses of all sizes.

Whether you’re a small local bakery or a multinational chain, understanding the power of reviews is the key to unlocking your business’s full potential in the online realm.

The Relationship of Local SEO & Customer Reviews

Before diving deep into reviews, it’s crucial to get a grasp on local SEO and its significance in improving your ranking. Here, we’ll uncover what local SEO is and the pivotal role customer reviews play in it.

What’s Local SEO Anyway

Think of the last time you searched for “best tacos near me.” That’s a local search. Mark McShane, Founder & CEO of First Aid at Work Course said, “Local SEO is the behind-the-scenes magic that makes sure your taco joint (or any business) shows up when folks are hunting for what you offer. 

It’s like being the loudest cheerleader in a massive stadium, making sure everyone hears about your epic tacos.”

Online Reviews: Your Business’s Best Friend (or Worst Enemy)

Ever picked a restaurant just because it had awesome reviews? That’s the power of customer feedback. When people rave about your spicy salsa or your top-notch service, it’s like they’re giving your business a gold star. 

And guess what? Search engines love gold stars. The more positive reviews you have, the more likely search engines think, “This place is happening!” and bump you up in the rankings. But watch out for those negative reviews. Just like one burnt taco can ruin a meal, a bad review can hurt your online rep. So, always aim for those 5-star ratings to increase your brand visibility!

Consistency is Key 

Imagine your business is a puzzle. Every piece, from your opening hours to your address, should fit perfectly. Johnny Dixon, Marketing Director at Accountant Edinburgh, shares, “If your website says you close at 10 PM, but your Yelp page says midnight, it’s like having two puzzle pieces that just won’t fit. And trust me, folks notice. Like Tom, who drove across town for a midnight snack, only to find your doors locked. Ouch.”

The Ultimate Goal of Local SEO

It’s all about being the star of the show. When someone’s looking for what you offer, you want your business to take center stage. 

It’s like auditioning for the lead role in a play and nailing it. With the right Local SEO moves and a bunch of glowing online reviews, you’re not just in the spotlight; you’re the talk of the town.

The Rise of Customer Reviews

The digital landscape has amplified the voice of the customer. Let’s delve into the growing prominence of online reviews and how they’ve become a cornerstone in influencing consumer choices.

Why Everyone’s Talking About Online Reviews?

Remember when you’d ask your neighbor about the best plumber in town? Well, times have changed. Now, we turn to online reviews. They’ve become the digital “word of mouth” that everyone listens to. 

Whether it’s a new restaurant, a hair salon, or a yoga studio, before we step foot inside, we check out what others are saying online. And for businesses, these reviews are like gold. They can boost your online presence, making you the go-to spot in local searches.

Click or Skip? Reviews Decide

Imagine you’re scrolling online for a new pair of sneakers. Two stores pop up. One has a bunch of 5-star reviews raving about the shoe quality and swift delivery. The other? Crickets. No reviews. Which one would you click on? 

Ashley Newman, Content Director at Accountant Glasgow, observed, “Most of us would go for the one with glowing reviews. It’s simple: online reviews influence our choices. They’re like those little nudges that say, ‘Hey, this place is worth your time (and money).’”

The Impact of Positive and Negative Reviews

Every review, whether it sings praises or points out flaws, has an impact. Here, we’ll dissect how positive and negative feedback can shape a business’s online image.

Riding the Positive Review Wave

Imagine you’re at a party, and everyone’s raving about this new cafe downtown. Your curiosity is piqued, right? You’d probably check it out the next day. That’s what positive online reviews do for businesses. They’re like a crowd at a party, all talking about how awesome you are. 

When your business gets a bunch of 5-star reviews, it’s like getting a standing ovation. People see it, and they think, “I’ve got to experience this for myself!” This buzz not only gives your reputation a big boost but also drives curious folks straight to your doorstep, both digitally and literally.

The Downside of a Thumbs-Down

Now, let’s flip the coin. Remember that one time a friend warned you about a movie, and you skipped it? Negative reviews work the same way. One bad review might not be a deal-breaker, but a series of them? It’s like a red flag waving, telling potential customers, “Proceed with caution.” 

These reviews can put a dent in your reputation. It’s like having a stain on a white shirt; it’s the first thing people notice. And while it’s natural for businesses to have a mix of reviews, a pile-up of negative ones can make folks hesitant to give you their time or money.

Case Study: Kline Home Exteriors’ Experience with Online Reviews

Kline Home Exteriors used our platform, Reviegrower.

Kline Home Exteriors, with its foundation laid by five professionals, has a cumulative experience of over 60 years in the roofing industry. However, their online footprint, specifically in terms of reviews, was minimal, with only 4 reviews to their name.

The Shift in Online Reviews

Upon implementing a focused approach to gather online feedback, Kline Home Exteriors observed the following changes:

  • Initial Surge: Within the initial two days, there was an addition of 10 new reviews.
  • Annual Growth: Over the span of the first year, the number of reviews grew by 223.
  • Google Reviews: As of the latest data, they have accumulated 260 reviews on Google.
See also  The Rise of DevOps in 2024: Enhancing Collaboration and Efficiency in Software Projects

The increase in online reviews also seemed to correlate with other changes:

  • Website Traffic: There was a noted 25% increase in the traffic to their website.
  • Search Engine Rankings: Kline Home Exteriors began to appear more prominently in search results, often ranking within the top 5 on Google.
  • Lead Conversion: With a more substantial online review presence, there appeared to be an improvement in lead conversion, possibly indicating enhanced trust from potential clients.

The experience of Kline Home Exteriors underscores the potential influence of online reviews on various facets of a business, from website traffic to search engine rankings.

The Mechanics Behind Search Algorithms

At the heart of every search engine, be it Google, Bing, or any other, lies a complex set of rules and calculations known as algorithms. Think of them as the recipe that search engines use to whip up search results. 

Jeremy Ferguson, Owner of PixelPoynt SEO Agency said, “When you type in a query, these algorithms sift through billions of web pages, analyzing factors like content quality, website structure, and user engagement, to serve you the most relevant results. It’s like searching for the best chocolate cake recipe and being presented with the most popular and trusted ones first.”

Now, where do reviews fit into this recipe? 

Well, search engines are all about user experience. They want to show results that users will find valuable. And what’s a better indicator of value than feedback from other users? 

When a business gets a lot of positive reviews, it signals to search engines that people have had good experiences there. On the flip side, a series of negative reviews might indicate potential issues.

Moreover, the frequency of online reviews also plays a role. A business that consistently gets feedback (good or bad) indicates that it’s active and engaging with its customers. Search engines see this as a sign of relevance and might give such businesses a nudge up in rankings.

Lastly, the content of the reviews can also be crucial. Detailed reviews might contain keywords or phrases that potential customers are searching for, further influencing how a business ranks for specific queries.

Quality Over Quantity. Always.

It’s no secret that not everything we see online is genuine. This holds true for reviews as well. While a large number of positive reviews can boost a business’s image, it’s essential that these reviews are authentic. 

Fake reviews, often easily spotted by discerning customers, can erode trust. They might be overly generic, sound too promotional, or even be copied from other sources. And the repercussions? Beyond just losing potential customers, businesses can face penalties from search engines or review platforms. 

Robert Dalton, Founder of HUALALAI, shares, “Genuine feedback, even if it’s not all glowing, adds authenticity. It shows that real people are engaging with the business, sharing their honest experiences and that the business values transparency.”

And how should you as a business respond? 

Well, ever read a negative review followed by a thoughtful response from the business? It can change the entire narrative. How businesses respond to reviews, both praise and criticism, speaks volumes about their values and customer service. 

A timely and constructive response to a negative review can showcase a business’s commitment to customer satisfaction, potentially turning a dissatisfied customer into a loyal one. Similarly, thanking customers for positive feedback fosters goodwill. 

Sumeer Kaur, Founder of Lehenga said, “From a search ranking perspective, active engagement with online reviews can signal to search engines that a business is active and values its online reputation, possibly influencing its position in search results.”

Beyond Google: The Power of Third-Party Review Sites

While Google is undeniably a giant in the search world, it’s not the only player when it comes to reviews. Platforms like Yelp, TripAdvisor, and many others have carved out significant niches, especially in sectors like dining, travel, and local services. 

For many consumers, these sites are the go-to places to check out reviews before making decisions. 

So, how does this influence local search rankings? Well, search engines aim to provide the most relevant and comprehensive information. Eran Mizrahi, CEO of Ingredient Brothers, shares, “When a business consistently receives positive feedback across multiple platforms, it can be seen as a strong indicator of its quality and reliability.” 

Moreover, these third-party reviews can sometimes appear in search results, offering another avenue for potential customers to discover and engage with a business.

Also, there’s undeniable value in showcasing third-party reviews directly on your business website. 

For starters, it offers social proof. When visitors see real feedback from platforms they trust, it can enhance credibility and trustworthiness.

Additionally, integrating these reviews can keep visitors on your site longer, reducing bounce rates and potentially improving search rankings and Local SEO. It’s also a way to provide a more holistic view of customer experiences, showing that you’re not just cherry-picking the best reviews but are transparent about all feedback. 

Plus, with the right tools and widgets, businesses can make this integration seamless, ensuring a smooth user experience.


Today, where information is at our fingertips, the voice of the customer has taken center stage. Online reviews, once just a platform for feedback, have evolved into powerful tools that significantly influence local search rankings and, by extension, a business’s success. 

From understanding the intricacies of search algorithms to recognizing the value of genuine feedback and the influence of third-party review platforms, it’s clear that the landscape of local search is intricately tied to the experiences and opinions of consumers.

Businesses, whether small local shops or large enterprises, must recognize and adapt to this reality. Engaging with reviews, ensuring authenticity, and leveraging feedback across platforms are no longer optional strategies but essential components of a robust online presence.


Q1. How Can Businesses Encourage Customers to Leave Positive Online Reviews?

Encouraging customers to leave positive online reviews involves creating a positive and memorable experience. Consider implementing the following strategies:
Provide Exceptional Service: Ensure that your products or services meet or exceed customer expectations. A satisfied customer is more likely to leave a positive review.
Request Feedback: Politely ask satisfied customers for feedback, either in person or through follow-up emails. Make it easy for them to share their experiences.
Utilize Review Platforms: Direct customers to specific review platforms like Google, Yelp, or industry-specific platforms where their feedback can have the most impact.
Incentivize Reviews: Consider offering incentives like discounts, loyalty points, or exclusive deals for customers who take the time to leave a positive review.

Q2. How Do Businesses Effectively Handle Negative Online Reviews?

Dealing with negative online reviews requires a thoughtful and constructive approach to mitigate any potential harm. Here’s a guide on managing negative reviews:
Respond Promptly: Address negative reviews in a timely manner. Acknowledge the customer’s concerns and express a genuine desire to resolve the issue.
Stay Professional: Keep responses professional and avoid becoming defensive. Apologize for any inconvenience and offer a solution or steps to rectify the problem.
Take the Conversation Offline: Encourage further discussion or resolution privately. Provide contact information or ask the customer to reach out to your customer service team directly.
Showcase Positive Responses: When a resolution is reached, update the review to reflect the positive outcome. This demonstrates to potential customers that you actively address concerns and prioritize customer satisfaction.